One job. Many benefits.

By David Parks OBE, CEO and Founder of The Skill Mill

Public policy sees unemployment, offending, educational disadvantage and poor health as separate problems, each requiring its own programme, budget eand government department response. But young people do not experience these challenges separately. They experience them simultaneously.
Why shouldn't our solutions reflect that?
Alan Milburn's final review, From a Welfare State to a Working State: A New Settlement for the Next Generation, published on 17 November, makes a compelling case for fundamentally changing how we support young people into employment.
Its central message is one we should all recognise: young people are not short of aspiration. They are too often short of opportunity.
Nearly one million young people aged 16 to 24 are not in education, employment or training. Six in ten have never had a job. Milburn warns that without fundamental reform, Britain risks losing another generation to economic inactivity, with enormous consequences for individuals, families, public services and the wider economy.
The review rightly argues that the problem cannot be solved through welfare reform alone. It requires a much more coordinated approach to employment, education, health, skills and the way government itself operates.
And there is a fundamental contradiction at its heart. We repeatedly tell young people they need to become work-ready, yet too often we fail to provide them with meaningful opportunities to develop those skills.
We cannot prepare young people indefinitely for jobs that do not exist or that nobody is prepared to offer them.
For young people involved in the youth justice system, the barriers are particularly acute. Milburn's earlier interim report highlighted that children supervised by Youth Offending Teams are more than twice as likely to spend six months or longer outside education, employment or training.
Disrupted education, poor qualifications, difficult family circumstances, limited work experience and the stigma associated with offending can combine to make that first opportunity almost impossible to secure.
Yet these are precisely the young people for whom a positive experience of employment can make an enormous difference.
In Newcastle in 2013, we established The Skill Mill around a relatively simple proposition: instead of preparing young people indefinitely for jobs they might never get, why not employ them directly?
We offer young people aged 16 to 18 who are involved in the youth justice system six months of paid employment, working in small, supervised teams on environmental improvement projects. They restore waterways, reduce flood risk, improve green spaces and deliver work of genuine value to communities.
Alongside their employment, they gain recognised qualifications, develop practical and interpersonal skills, receive mentoring and are supported to progress into further employment, education or training.
They are not simply attending another employability course or completing an unpaid placement. They are employees. They earn wages. They have colleagues, responsibilities and people depending on them.
And they can see the results of their work.
One job. Many benefits.
This is where the wider significance of the model becomes apparent.
First, there is employment itself. Young people gain experience, income, structure and an understanding of workplace expectations. For many, this is their first opportunity to experience the dignity and independence that earning a wage can provide.
Second, there is education. Learning does not always need to begin in a classroom. Practical work creates opportunities to develop skills, achieve qualifications and build confidence through real experience. Qualifications must be relevant and achievable.
Third, there is the potential to reduce offending. Meaningful activity, legitimate income, trusted adult relationships and a different sense of identity can help young people begin to see themselves not through the lens of their previous behaviour, but through what they are capable of contributing. This identity shift can be critical. A credible job can change not only how others see a young person, but how they see themselves.
Fourth, there are health and wellbeing benefits. Working outdoors, undertaking physical activity, developing friendships and experiencing achievement can support physical and mental wellbeing. Young people involved in our programme have described increased confidence, self-belief and pride in their accomplishments. They describe feeling physically stronger and less stressed.
And fifth, there is the environmental dividend. Cleaner waterways, improved green spaces, healthier local environments and more resilient communities are not incidental by-products. They are valuable public outcomes in their own right.
When we restore a river, the benefits flow far beyond the water itself. Habitats improve, communities are better protected and the environment becomes healthier. Giving a young person a meaningful job can have a similar ripple effect, extending far beyond their own life to their families and the wider community.
Over the past decade, The Skill Mill has grown from a local Newcastle initiative into a programme working across multiple local authority areas.
Our independently evaluated Life Chances Fund programme supported 243 young people. Of these, 188 achieved recognised qualifications and 179 completed six months of employment. Most importantly, there were 212 non-reoffending outcomes.
These are achievements worth celebrating, but we should also be clear about the challenges. Sustained progression into further employment or training has proved more difficult, and the outcomes recorded do not, on their own, establish how much change can be attributed to the programme.
That is why the next stage of The Skill Mill's development matters so much. A new £5.6 million partnership supported by the Youth Endowment Fund will expand the model nationally, working with Bridges Outcomes Partnerships and local authorities, while undertaking rigorous independent evaluation, including a randomised controlled trial.
We want to establish not simply whether the programme delivers positive experiences, but whether it produces lasting changes in young people's lives.
Creating jobs, not just preparing people for them
One of the most welcome recommendations in Milburn's final report is the proposal to make it easier and less costly for employers to recruit young people who have been excluded from education and work.
The review proposes a £3,000 payment to employers hiring young people who have been NEET for six months, with an additional £2,000 premium for small businesses employing fewer than 50 people. Further financial support is proposed for employers taking on young people facing significant additional barriers.
This is a welcome recognition that preparing young people for employment is only half the challenge. Employers also need incentives, confidence and practical support to create those opportunities.
But financial incentives alone will not be enough.
For young people facing multiple barriers, the cost of effective supervision, mentoring, training and ongoing support can be considerable. Simply offering an employer £5,000 does not guarantee that a young person will remain in work, develop their capabilities or progress into a sustainable career.
We should distinguish between creating a job and creating a job in which a young person has a genuine chance of succeeding.
Social enterprises have a particular contribution to make here.
By combining commercial activity with social purpose, they can create employment opportunities for people whom conventional recruitment processes may overlook. They can build training, mentoring, reasonable adjustments and progression support into the employment model itself.
It is particularly encouraging that Milburn explicitly recognises the role of social enterprises and supported businesses in creating paid jobs, including for disabled young people. He also envisages social enterprises, charities and community organisations helping deliver the new locally commissioned Youth Opportunity Services.
This recognition should extend to social enterprises working with other groups facing substantial barriers, including young people involved in youth justice.
And we should not overlook the opportunity to intervene earlier. The Skill Mill's experience is primarily with 16–18-year-olds. Preventing a young person from becoming persistently NEET in the first place is surely preferable to waiting until they have spent years outside education and employment.
Making public procurement work harder
The report also makes an important recommendation about public procurement.
The review calls for youth employment to become a mandatory social value consideration in relevant major government contracts above £5 million, and for stronger commitments to young people's employment within larger public contracts.
This is a significant opportunity.
Local authorities and other public bodies already spend substantial sums maintaining parks, waterways, public spaces and community infrastructure. With appropriate commissioning and support, some of that expenditure could create supported employment for young people while still delivering the services communities need.
The Skill Mill demonstrates how environmental services can create both commercial value and social benefits. The same principle could be applied across a range of public services and industries.
But we should ensure that smaller social enterprises are not excluded because they lack the capacity to compete for major contracts. Public procurement should also encourage larger contractors to work with social enterprises and smaller local businesses, creating opportunities through their supply chains.
Public expenditure should not simply purchase services. Wherever possible, it should create opportunities.
The missing piece: commissioning for multiple outcomes
This brings us back to the challenge at the heart of the review.
What if we stopped treating unemployment, offending, poor educational outcomes and ill health as entirely separate policy problems?
What if we invested more deliberately in interventions capable of delivering benefits across several public services at once?
A young person who gains employment, achieves a qualification, builds confidence and avoids further involvement in the criminal justice system potentially creates benefits for the Department for Work and Pensions, the Ministry of Justice, the Department for Education, the NHS and the local community.
Yet the budgets, commissioning arrangements and accountability structures of those organisations remain largely separate.
How do we pay for interventions whose benefits are shared across several public services, when no single commissioner has the budget or incentive to fund them alone?
This is one of the most persistent challenges facing preventative public services. The costs of supporting a young person may fall on a local authority or youth justice service today, while the benefits of reduced offending, improved employment, better health and reduced dependence on benefits may emerge years later across several different public budgets.
Outcomes-based commissioning offers one way of addressing this dilemma.
Through Social Outcomes Partnerships (SOPs), commissioners, delivery organisations, social investors and other partners can come together around a shared set of outcomes. Rather than funding activities alone, they can focus on measurable improvements in people's lives. Upfront investment can enable services to be delivered, while payments are linked to agreed outcomes.
The Government's £500 million Better Futures Fund presents an important opportunity to develop this approach at scale. Intended to support up to 200,000 children, young people and families over ten years, it seeks to encourage earlier intervention and more joined-up services through Social Outcomes Partnerships.
Significantly, Milburn's final review specifically recognises that the Better Futures Fund and impact investment can complement core public investment in achieving measurable outcomes.
Its potential significance extends beyond providing another source of funding. It offers an opportunity to rethink how public services are commissioned, bringing together organisations with different responsibilities around common objectives and recognising that the benefits of effective prevention rarely sit neatly within one departmental budget.
The Skill Mill's experience of the Life Chances Fund and our current Social Outcomes Partnership illustrates both the promise and the complexity of this approach.
Outcomes-based commissioning is not a magic solution. It requires meaningful outcome measures, proportionate contracting, fair sharing of risks, including financial risks, and sufficient flexibility to respond to individual needs. Nor should providers be expected to carry financial risks that are properly the responsibility of government.
But done well, these partnerships can create the conditions for investing in prevention, encouraging collaboration and rewarding lasting improvements rather than simply paying for activity.
The real opportunity is to commission around the outcomes we want for young people, rather than the boundaries of the organisations responsible for delivering them.
This is not about spending the same pound five times or pretending that one intervention can solve every problem. It is about recognising the potential to achieve multiple outcomes from a single, carefully designed intervention and investment.
Turning a national ambition into local opportunities
The proposed Youth Opportunity Service offers a potentially important framework for making this happen.
By bringing together employment, education, health and practical support, with greater local responsibility and accountability, it could address the fragmentation that leaves too many young people navigating disconnected services.
The challenge will be to ensure that it does not simply become another layer of administration.
We need local systems that work with employers, social enterprises, Youth Justice Services, colleges and community organisations to create practical opportunities, not simply more referral pathways.
We also need a clear commitment to evidence. What matters is not how many young people are referred to a programme, attend a course or receive advice, but whether they gain meaningful employment, achieve qualifications, improve their wellbeing, avoid further offending where relevant, and sustain positive outcomes over time.
At the same time, we must be careful that a greater emphasis on employment does not weaken the financial security of young people who need it. Employment cannot replace appropriate healthcare, specialist support, housing or financial protection. Many young people require these services alongside opportunities to work.
Effective reform must combine opportunity with security, and support with realistic expectations.
The Milburn review recognises that we need a different balance between spending money after problems have become entrenched and investing earlier to prevent them.
The costs of persistent unemployment, repeated offending, poor health and exclusion do not fall on one public service. They accumulate across government and society.
We should therefore be much more interested in the combined social and economic value of prevention, rather than measuring success solely through departmental spending.
One job. Many benefits. A different future.
Milburn's review provides an ambitious framework for tackling a problem tolerated for far too long.
Its proposals to create more first jobs, improve apprenticeships, integrate health and employment support, harness public procurement and empower local services resonates heavily with us at The Skill Mill.
The next challenge is implementation.
The Skill Mill is not the only answer, and it would be wrong to suggest that one model is appropriate for every young person. But our experience illustrates what can happen when we bring employment, education, rehabilitation, wellbeing and environmental improvement together, rather than treating them as unrelated objectives.
The greatest benefit is not simply a qualification achieved, a wage earned or a waterway restored. It is the possibility of a young person beginning to see a different future for themselves, with employment, independence and opportunity within reach.
Sometimes the most effective way to help a young person become ready for work is to give them a job and the support to succeed in it.
And when that job creates multiple benefits for the young person and society, surely that is the opportunity we should be doing much more to create.

-09.png)



Comments